Blog
Why Most Companies Get Email Training Wrong (And What Actually Works)
You know what nobody talks about at industry conferences? The fact that 67% of workplace miscommunications stem from poorly written emails, yet most organisations treat email training like teaching someone to tie their shoelaces.
I've been running business communication workshops across Australia for nearly two decades now, and I can tell you with absolute certainty that the way we approach email training is fundamentally broken. Companies are spending thousands on generic courses that teach people to "be professional" and "use proper formatting" whilst completely missing the real issues that are costing them clients and damaging relationships every single day.
The Real Problem Isn't What You Think
Here's where most training providers get it wrong. They focus on grammar and structure when the actual problem is context and intent. I've seen beautifully formatted emails that have destroyed partnerships and informal messages that have sealed million-dollar deals.
The issue isn't that people don't know how to use spell check. It's that they don't understand the psychological impact of written communication in a digital-first workplace. When you remove tone of voice, facial expressions, and body language from communication, what remains needs to carry significantly more weight.
I learned this the hard way in 2019 when I sent what I thought was a perfectly reasonable follow-up email to a potential client in Brisbane. Professional tone, clear bullet points, proper sign-off. The client responded by terminating discussions. Turns out my "efficiency" came across as dismissive arrogance.
What Actually Works in Email Training
The most effective email writing training programs I've developed focus on three core elements that traditional courses completely ignore:
Emotional Intelligence in Digital Communication: Teaching people to recognise and convey emotional nuance through text. This isn't about adding smiley faces everywhere – it's about understanding how different personality types interpret written communication differently.
Context Switching Skills: The ability to adapt your writing style based on urgency, relationship dynamics, and organisational culture. An email to your direct report should have a completely different tone than one to a board member, yet most people use the same approach for both.
Recovery Techniques: What to do when emails go wrong. Because they will. Rather than pretending email miscommunications won't happen, we need to teach people how to repair relationships when they inevitably do.
Most training programs spend hours on signature formatting and subject line optimisation. Sure, these things matter, but they're like teaching someone to arrange deck chairs whilst the ship is sinking.
The Australian Business Context
Here's something that international training providers consistently get wrong when working with Australian businesses: our communication style is fundamentally different from corporate America or even the UK. We value directness, but we also expect a certain level of warmth and approachability.
I've worked with Melbourne-based teams who struggled with managing difficult conversations via email because their training taught them American-style corporate communication that felt cold and impersonal in our context.
The best email training acknowledges these cultural nuances. When you're writing to someone in Sydney, your approach should differ from communication with international partners. It's not about being less professional – it's about being authentically professional within our business culture.
Beyond the Basics: Advanced Email Strategy
What separates good email training from transformational email training is the inclusion of strategic thinking. Most people treat email as a reactive medium – someone sends them something, they respond. But email can be a powerful proactive business tool when used correctly.
I teach my clients to think of email as a relationship-building platform. Every message should either strengthen a professional relationship or move a business objective forward. Preferably both.
This means understanding timing (never send a complex proposal at 4:30 PM on a Friday), psychology (people respond differently to requests based on their communication preferences), and strategic sequencing (how one email sets up the next in a series).
Companies like Atlassian have built entire customer relationship strategies around thoughtful email communication. Their customer success team doesn't just send updates – they send emails that make customers feel valued and understood.
The Integration Challenge
Here's where most organisations completely drop the ball: they treat email training as a standalone skill rather than integrating it with their broader communication strategy.
Effective team development training should include email communication as part of a holistic approach to workplace interaction. Your email style should complement your meeting communication, your phone manner, and your written reports.
I've seen too many teams where individuals have excellent face-to-face communication skills but their email interactions create confusion and conflict. The disconnect is jarring and ultimately damaging to team cohesion.
The best organisations I work with treat email training as part of their cultural development, not just their skills development. They understand that how their people communicate in writing reflects and shapes their organisational values.
Measuring Success Differently
Traditional email training programs measure success through completion rates and satisfaction surveys. But what actually matters?
Response rates to important emails. Relationship quality indicators. Project completion times. Client retention rates. These are the metrics that show whether your email training is actually improving business outcomes.
I track a simple metric with my clients: email chain length. When people communicate more effectively, they resolve issues faster, which means shorter email chains. It's a surprisingly reliable indicator of communication effectiveness.
One manufacturing company in Adelaide reduced their average project email chains from 23 messages to 8 messages after implementing strategic email training. That's not just more efficient communication – it's significantly reduced project delivery times and improved client satisfaction.
The Future of Email Training
The landscape is changing rapidly. With AI tools becoming more prevalent, the focus of email training needs to shift from basic composition to strategic communication and relationship management.
People will increasingly use AI to help draft emails, but they'll still need to understand communication strategy, emotional intelligence, and relationship dynamics. These uniquely human skills become more valuable, not less, as technology handles the mechanical aspects of writing.
The most forward-thinking organisations are already adapting their training approaches to focus on these higher-level skills while teaching people how to effectively collaborate with AI writing tools.
Our Favourite Blogs:
Remember, email training isn't about creating perfect writers – it's about creating effective communicators who can build relationships and drive results through digital channels. Everything else is just window dressing.
The companies that understand this distinction will have a significant competitive advantage in our increasingly digital business environment. The ones that don't will continue wondering why their "professional" emails aren't getting the responses they expect.